In-depth guide
Stuck on a Career Decision? What Is Really Holding You Up
Why can't I decide? A guide to the eight common obstacles in a career decision, from missing information to family hopes, and the next step for each.
By TraitLume Editorial8 min read
Most career tests try to answer one question: what would suit me? For many people, that is not the question keeping them up at night. They already have a few ideas, perhaps a list of interests, perhaps a family with strong views. What they cannot work out is a different question entirely: why can't I decide?
This guide is about that second question. It explains a well-researched way of thinking about career indecision, the eight areas our Crossroads test looks at, and why matching your next step to the real obstacle saves so much time and frustration.
First, one reassurance. Being undecided is not a flaw, and it is not a disorder. It is a normal stage of a big decision. For many people it is a sign that they are taking the decision seriously.
Indecision is not one thing
In the 1990s the Israeli psychologist Itamar Gati and his colleagues proposed that career indecision is not a single problem but several. Drawing on decision theory, Gati, Krausz and Osipow (1996) sorted the difficulties people meet into three broad families:
- Not being ready to decide: the decision is not getting your energy yet, choosing is hard for you in general, or your expectations make the choice feel heavier than it is.
- Lacking information: about yourself, about the options, or about how to get from here to there.
- Having information that does not fit together: your own wishes pull in different directions, or they clash with the hopes of the people around you.
Their questionnaire has since been studied in many countries and languages, and the three-family structure has held up well. Crossroads is an original reflection built on that taxonomy. It uses its own statements, not those of any published questionnaire, and it has not yet been validated in a study of its own.
The eight areas, and the step that fits each
The most useful insight from this research is practical: each kind of difficulty calls for a different kind of help. Gathering more information will not resolve a disagreement with your family. A heart-to-heart will not tell you what a nurse actually does all day. Here is how the eight areas in Crossroads line up with the steps that tend to help.
Readiness to decide
Low momentum. The decision keeps getting pushed to "later". You may feel little urgency, or quietly hope the answer will arrive by itself. This is very often a sign of tiredness or a full life, not laziness. What helps is small and concrete: one calendar block a week, one action per block, written down.
General indecision. Choosing is hard for you in many areas of life, not only careers. You may seek reassurance before committing, or revisit a choice long after making it. This usually comes with real strengths, such as care and thoroughness, and a strong wish to avoid regret. What helps is structure: a decision date, a cap on the number of options you compare, and a clear rule for what "good enough" means.
That last idea has research behind it. Barry Schwartz and colleagues (2002) distinguished maximizers, who try to find the very best option, from satisficers, who look for one that meets their standards and then stop. In their studies, people with a strong maximizing tendency tended to report more regret and lower happiness and life satisfaction. Deciding in advance what "good enough" looks like is not settling. It is protecting yourself from an endless search.
All-or-nothing beliefs. Beliefs such as "there is one perfect career for me", "this choice is for life" or "an expert should be able to tell me the answer" are common and understandable. They also freeze decisions that could be made step by step. What helps is gently testing them: most people change jobs several times, many change fields, and many careers that fit well were never planned. Career researchers Mitchell, Levin and Krumboltz (1999) argued that unplanned events play a large part in most careers and that curiosity, persistence and flexibility help people make the most of them. No test, including this one, can reveal a single right answer. It can only help you take a good next step.
Missing information
Gaps in self-knowledge. You are unsure what truly interests you, what you need from a job or what you do well. Reflection helps, but this gap closes fastest through trying things and noticing your reactions: a short course, a volunteer role, a side project. An interest test such as Holland Career Interests and a values test such as What Matters at Work can give you words for what you find.
Gaps in knowing the options. You know little about what certain jobs involve day to day, what they pay or what their prospects are, or you are not sure your information is reliable. This gap closes quickly with focused research: occupational databases such as O*NET OnLine in the United States or Job Bank in Canada, and above all conversations with people who do the work.
Gaps in knowing the route. You know roughly where you want to go but not how to get there: the steps, the training, the qualifications or where to find trustworthy advice. For newcomers to a country it can include the question of whether earlier qualifications will be recognized. What helps is mapping the route backwards from the goal and finding one person or organization that knows the path.
Conflicting pulls
Inner conflict. Several options appeal equally. What you enjoy and what you are good at point different ways. Security and meaning compete. Inner conflict usually means you want many good things. It eases when priorities become clear, for example by ranking what matters most, imagining which choice you would regret not making in ten years, or looking for a path that combines two options in stages.
Outside pressures. The hopes, duties and opinions of family, partner or community weigh on your choice. In many families, career decisions are made together, and parents' and elders' views come from love, experience and real responsibilities. Research by Fouad and colleagues (2016), with participants in India and the United States, described family influence as several things at once: practical information, financial support, shared values and beliefs, and expectations. Some of these help a great deal; some add weight.
A high score here does not mean your family is a problem. It means the different views have not yet been brought together. What helps is a prepared conversation rather than a battle: explaining what you have learned, listening for the worry beneath the advice, sometimes involving a respected relative or mentor, and considering staged paths that honor both your wishes and your responsibilities.
A simple shape for the decision itself
Once you know what is in the way, the decision process itself can be quite simple. Gati and Asher (2001) described a three-stage approach that many counselors use:
- Prescreen: narrow a wide field to a shortlist of perhaps five to seven options, using the few things that matter most to you.
- Explore in depth: research each shortlisted option properly, ideally by talking to people and trying small pieces of the work.
- Choose: pick the option that fits best, and name a realistic backup.
The organizational researcher Herminia Ibarra, in her book Working Identity (2003), argued something similar from a different angle: people who change careers well rarely think their way to a new identity first and then act. More often they act their way into clarity through small experiments, new connections and trial projects. Thinking and doing work best together.
What if nothing comes out as a problem?
Some people finish Crossroads with no area in the elevated range, and their result reads "Ready to Choose", or "Clear Road Ahead" when every area comes out very low. That usually reflects genuine readiness. In that second case, the result adds one gentle, honest check: how did you arrive at your direction? Psychologists who study identity have noted that commitment can come from real exploration or be adopted from others without much questioning. Either path can lead somewhere good. It is simply worth knowing which one you took. And if several areas sit just below the line, the result is called "Almost Clear": one small step in each often clears the way.
And if several areas come out high at once, that is common too. The areas feed each other: missing information can make inner conflict feel worse, and outside pressure can drain momentum. Start with the area that feels most familiar or most urgent. Progress there often eases the others.
When it feels heavier than a decision
Career decisions can arrive at hard moments: after a job loss, during a move, alongside illness or family strain. Feeling stuck is normal. But if you have also felt low or hopeless most days for two weeks or more, or the weight of the decision is affecting your sleep, appetite or everyday life, please talk with a doctor, a counselor or someone you trust. If you ever feel unsafe or in crisis, contact your local emergency number or a crisis line right away. Crossroads is a reflection tool. It is not a clinical assessment, and it cannot tell you how you are really doing.
A career counselor or adviser at a school, university, public employment service or newcomer organization can also help you turn your results into a plan. That kind of help is often free, and using it is a sign of good judgment, not weakness.
Using the result well
A few principles keep Crossroads useful:
- It does not choose a career for you. It shows what is holding the decision up and suggests what to do next.
- Your result is a snapshot. Obstacles shift as you move through a decision. Retaking it after a few weeks of action often shows a different picture, which usually means progress.
- It is yours. Results are private unless you choose to share them, and they must never be used to select, rank or reject anyone for a job, a course or anything else.
Find what is in the way
If a career decision has been sitting with you for a while, it may help to see what is actually holding it up. Take Crossroads in a quiet six minutes, with the decision in front of you in mind. You will see which areas are in the way, why they tend to happen and a concrete next step for each one.
Sources
- Gati, I., Krausz, M., & Osipow, S. H. (1996). A taxonomy of difficulties in career decision making. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 43(4), 510–526. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0167.43.4.510
- Gati, I., & Asher, I. (2001). Prescreening, in-depth exploration, and choice: From decision theory to career counseling practice. The Career Development Quarterly, 50(2), 140–157. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2161-0045.2001.tb00979.x
- Schwartz, B., Ward, A., Monterosso, J., Lyubomirsky, S., White, K., & Lehman, D. R. (2002). Maximizing versus satisficing: Happiness is a matter of choice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(5), 1178–1197. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.83.5.1178
- Mitchell, K. E., Levin, A. S., & Krumboltz, J. D. (1999). Planned happenstance: Constructing unexpected career opportunities. Journal of Counseling & Development, 77(2), 115–124. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1556-6676.1999.tb02431.x
- Fouad, N. A., Kim, S., Ghosh, A., Chang, W., & Figueiredo, C. (2016). Family influence on career decision making: Validation in India and the United States. Journal of Career Assessment, 24(1), 197–212. https://doi.org/10.1177/1069072714565782
- Ibarra, H. (2003). Working Identity: Unconventional Strategies for Reinventing Your Career. Harvard Business School Press.
Topics
- career decision
- indecision
- career change
- family expectations