In-depth guide
Work Values: What a Job Has to Give You Before It Feels Right
Pay, freedom, purpose or a good team? A guide to the eight work values, the research behind them, and how to use your ranking in real job choices.
By TraitLume Editorial8 min read
Two jobs can look identical on paper. Same title, same tasks, roughly the same salary. Yet one leaves you steady and quietly proud at the end of the week, and the other leaves you restless in a way you cannot quite name. Very often the difference is simple and personal: one job gives you what you need from work, and the other does not.
That idea has a name in career psychology: work values. This guide explains what work values are, where the research comes from, what the eight values in our What Matters at Work test describe, and how to use your own ranking when you weigh an offer, ask for a change or talk with your team.
What work values are, and what they are not
A work value is a reward you need a job to provide. Fair pay is one. So is being trusted to decide how to do your work, or having colleagues you genuinely like, or seeing that your effort makes a difference to someone.
It helps to separate three questions that are easy to blur together:
- Interests: what kind of work you enjoy doing (building, helping, organizing, creating).
- Abilities: what you are able to do well, now or with training.
- Values: what the job must give back to you for you to be satisfied and stay.
A person can love the work itself, be very good at it, and still leave because the job never offers security, recognition or room to breathe. Values are the part people most often skip when choosing a job, and most often name when explaining why they left.
Where the idea comes from
The most influential research on work values began at the University of Minnesota in the 1960s, in a long program led by René Dawis and Lloyd Lofquist. Their Theory of Work Adjustment rests on a two-way idea of fit. You tend to be satisfied with a job when it rewards what you value. The job, in turn, tends to be satisfied with you when you can do what it requires. When both sides fit, people usually stay longer and do better; when one side drifts, something has to adjust, or someone leaves.
Over decades of study, the Minnesota team grouped the many rewards people look for into six broad families. The US Department of Labor's occupational database, O*NET, later used those same six families to describe the rewards typical of hundreds of occupations. That is why you will see the same six names across many career tools.
Our test measures those six classic families and adds two that working people now name again and again:
- Achievement: using your abilities and seeing real results.
- Independence: choosing your methods, trying your own ideas, owning your decisions.
- Recognition: credit, advancement, the chance to lead and a respected standing.
- Relationships: good colleagues, cooperation and work that never asks you to act against your conscience.
- Support: fair policies, a manager who backs you, and the training and tools to do the job.
- Security & Conditions: fair pay, a stable position, benefits and a safe, decent place to work.
- Flexibility & Balance: some say over when and where you work, and room for the rest of your life.
- Purpose & Impact: work that means something and makes a difference beyond the paycheck.
The last two do not come from the original Minnesota framework. They draw on newer research about meaningful work and about how jobs fit around family, health and caring duties. We say so plainly in the test, because honesty about where an idea comes from is part of using it well.
Why your answers are compared with your own average
Here is the practical problem with any work values questionnaire: almost everything sounds good. Who does not want fair pay, kind colleagues, freedom and meaning? If you rate each value on its own, many people end up rating everything highly, and the result says very little.
So What Matters at Work compares your answers with your own average. The result shows what you place above and below everything else. A value near the bottom of your profile may still matter to you; it simply matters less than the others when they compete. That is exactly the information you need, because no real job offers everything at once.
There is a trade-off to this method, and it is worth knowing. Scores built this way describe the shape of your priorities. They cannot be compared directly with another person's scores. If your colleague's Recognition bar is longer than yours, that does not mean they care more about recognition than you do in any absolute sense. It means recognition sits higher in their own order.
No value is nobler than another
Career advice sometimes carries a quiet hierarchy: passion and purpose at the top, pay and security somewhere below, as if caring about a steady income were a failure of imagination. We think that view leaves out most of the world's working people.
A stable salary lets people plan, support a family, repay debts, send money home or simply sleep at night. For someone building a life in a new country, or carrying responsibility for parents and children, putting Security & Conditions first is not a lack of ambition. It is often love in practical form. In the same way, Recognition is not vanity. In many cultures a respected position is a shared achievement that honors the people who sacrificed to make it possible. And Flexibility & Balance is not a sign of low commitment; for parents, carers and people managing their health, it is often what makes commitment sustainable.
The point of the test is not to reach a "better" order. It is to know your own.
What the research says, and what it does not
The core idea, that people are more satisfied when a job offers what they value, has solid support. A large meta-analysis by Amy Kristof-Brown and colleagues (2005) combined studies of different kinds of fit at work. Fit between a person and their job was clearly associated with higher job satisfaction and organizational commitment and with lower intention to quit. Most of those studies rely on self-reports, and many measure everything at one point in time, so they show association more firmly than cause. Still, the pattern is consistent.
The two newer values rest on their own literatures. Reviews of meaningful work, such as Rosso, Dekas and Wrzesniewski (2010), describe the many sources of meaning people find at work, from the task itself to colleagues, the organization's mission and a sense of contributing to others. Research on flexibility is more nuanced than headlines suggest. A meta-analysis by Allen and colleagues (2013) found that flexible arrangements are linked to somewhat less work–family conflict, but the effects were small and depended on the kind of flexibility: whether it concerned when or where people worked, and whether they actually used it or merely had it on paper. That is one reason the test asks about both time and place, and why it is worth asking an employer about practice, not just policy.
And one honest note about our own instrument: the statements in What Matters at Work are original, and this version has not yet been validated in a published study. The theory behind it is well supported; the specific questionnaire is new. Treat your profile as a thoughtful mirror, not a measurement to the decimal point.
Work values, life values and interests
People sometimes ask how this differs from a general values test. The short answer is scope. A life values model, such as the one behind our Schwartz values test, describes what guides your whole life: tradition, benevolence, achievement, stimulation and so on, arranged in a circle where neighboring values support each other. What Matters at Work asks a narrower question: what does a job have to give you? The two often agree, but they answer different questions, and a person can value adventure in life while wanting a very secure job.
Work values also do not tell you which career to choose. They describe what a job must offer, not what you would enjoy doing. Pair your result with an interest test such as Holland Career Interests, and with real conversations and small experiments, to explore careers that fit both.
Using your result in real decisions
A ranked list is only useful if it changes what you notice. Here are a few ways to put yours to work.
When you weigh a job offer. Look past the title to the conditions that touch your top values. If Support leads your profile, try to meet your future manager and ask how new people are trained. If Independence leads, ask who decides the method and how often you will be expected to check in. If Flexibility & Balance leads, ask what a normal week looks like, including evenings, rather than relying on the written policy. If Security & Conditions leads, read the contract type, the benefits and how pay is reviewed. Asking these questions is entirely appropriate.
When two good options compete. Try a simple exercise. Imagine each option offers only four of the eight values, and decide which set you would choose. Repeat with different pairs. Real choices force trade-offs, and noticing which ones feel easy and which feel painful often reveals priorities a questionnaire cannot.
When a job feels "fine" but something is missing. Look at the best and worst periods of your working life, or your studies or volunteering. What was present in the good times? What was missing in the hard ones? The answer often points straight at one or two values.
When you talk with a manager. Your profile gives you words for a conversation that is otherwise hard to start. "I do my best work when I can see the result of what I build" is more useful than "I'm a bit bored."
Work values in teams
Teams can get real value from sharing their profiles, as long as everyone chooses to. A team where one person leads with Recognition and another with Relationships may disagree about how credit should be given, and simply naming that difference can ease a lot of friction.
What the test is not for is just as important. What Matters at Work is not designed or validated for selection. It must never be used to hire, reject, promote or rank anyone. An organization sees your result only if you choose to share it, and our terms allow it to be used only for reflection, development and conversation, such as onboarding or a one-to-one meeting.
Your values can change
Work values are more changeable than personality. Life stage, caring duties, money pressures and experience all shift what matters most. Flexibility and security often rise when family needs grow; purpose sometimes rises later in a career. If you retake the test at a turning point, such as a new child, a move or a career change, a different order is not a contradiction. It is information.
Find your own order
If you are weighing a decision, or simply wondering why a perfectly good job does not feel quite right, it can help to see your priorities laid out plainly. Take What Matters at Work in a calm seven minutes. You will get your top three values, the ones where you can be most flexible, and questions to bring to your next conversation about work. Your results stay private unless you choose to share them.
Sources
- Dawis, R. V., & Lofquist, L. H. (1984). A Psychological Theory of Work Adjustment: An Individual-Differences Model and Its Applications. University of Minnesota Press.
- Kristof-Brown, A. L., Zimmerman, R. D., & Johnson, E. C. (2005). Consequences of individuals' fit at work: A meta-analysis of person–job, person–organization, person–group, and person–supervisor fit. Personnel Psychology, 58(2), 281–342. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.2005.00672.x
- Rosso, B. D., Dekas, K. H., & Wrzesniewski, A. (2010). On the meaning of work: A theoretical integration and review. Research in Organizational Behavior, 30, 91–127. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.riob.2010.09.001
- Allen, T. D., Johnson, R. C., Kiburz, K. M., & Shockley, K. M. (2013). Work–family conflict and flexible work arrangements: Deconstructing flexibility. Personnel Psychology, 66(2), 345–376. https://doi.org/10.1111/peps.12012
- O*NET Resource Center. Work Values (content model elements 1.B.2). https://www.onetcenter.org/dictionary/30.2/text/work_values.html
Topics
- work values
- job satisfaction
- career choices
- person–job fit