Skip to content

In-depth guide

Thinking Style: How You Like to Think, and Why It Isn't IQ

Depth, curiosity, careful reasoning, intuition, open-mindedness and ease with ambiguity: a guide to six thinking preferences. Not an IQ test.

By TraitLume Editorial8 min read

Give the same problem to two people and watch what happens. One wants to sit with it for an evening; the other wants a quick answer and a next step. One lists every option; the other simply knows. One enjoys the open question; the other feels unsettled until it is closed.

Neither is smarter. They are using different styles: habits and preferences in how they like to use their minds. This guide explains what thinking styles are, the research behind the six dimensions in our Thinking Style test, and how to use your profile to learn, decide and work with people who think differently.

First, what this is not

Let us be clear from the start: Thinking Style is not an IQ test, and it does not measure ability.

An intelligence test gives you problems with correct answers and counts how many you solve. It measures performance. Thinking Style has no right answers at all. It asks what you enjoy and how you tend to approach things, and every answer is equally valid. It measures preference.

Preferences and abilities are different things. A person can love hard puzzles without being especially quick at them. A person who dislikes long analysis can still be very good at it when it is needed. Research supports this distinction: a large review and meta-analysis by von Stumm and Ackerman (2013) found that a taste for intellectual activity and measured intellectual ability are positively related, but only modestly. Plenty of people enjoy thinking more than their test scores would suggest, and plenty are more capable than their preferences would suggest.

So your results say nothing about how capable, educated or intelligent you are. A high score is not "better", and a low score is not a warning. Each end of each dimension has real advantages.

It is also not a "learning styles" test. The popular idea that people learn best when teaching is matched to a preferred style (visual, auditory and so on) has not held up well when tested properly, as Pashler and colleagues (2008) showed in a careful review. Thinking styles describe how you like to approach problems and decisions. They are not a prescription for how you must be taught.

The six dimensions

The test draws on several decades of research on what psychologists call thinking dispositions. Each of the six dimensions has its own research tradition. Our statements are original; the ideas are not new.

Deep Engagement

How much you enjoy sustained, effortful thinking for its own sake. In 1982, John Cacioppo and Richard Petty described the need for cognition: the tendency to seek out and enjoy thinking hard. People high on this dimension like to stay with a problem until it yields. People lower on it prefer to think hard when there is a good reason to, and keep everyday choices simple. That is not laziness; it is an efficient use of attention.

Wide Curiosity

How far your interests roam. Research on curiosity has shown that it comes in several forms, and that the wish to explore widely differs from the wish to go deep. People high on Wide Curiosity follow tangents happily and connect ideas from unrelated fields. People lower on it focus on a few chosen areas and find satisfaction in mastery rather than variety. One goes wide; the other goes deep.

Deliberate Reasoning

How much you like to work things out step by step: gathering facts, weighing options and checking the logic before deciding. People high on this dimension feel most confident when a choice has been reasoned through. People lower on it prefer to decide and adjust as they go.

Intuitive Sense

How much you trust hunches, first impressions and quick reads of people and situations. People high on this dimension often know before they can say why.

Here is the surprising part. You might expect Deliberate Reasoning and Intuitive Sense to be opposites, so that being high on one means being low on the other. Research says otherwise. Rosemary Pacini and Seymour Epstein (1999) found that a rational style and an intuitive (experiential) style are largely independent tendencies. Many people rely strongly on both; some rely on neither very much. That is why the test measures them separately, and why your profile can show both as leading styles at once.

Open Revision

How readily you welcome challenge and update your views. Jonathan Baron called this actively open-minded thinking: the willingness to look for reasons you might be wrong and to weigh evidence against what you already believe. Stanovich and West (1997) found that people who described themselves this way were better at evaluating arguments on their merits rather than on whether they agreed with the conclusion. At the other end are people with steady convictions, who change their minds carefully and only for good reason. That steadiness has its own value: it gives others something reliable to work with.

Comfort with Ambiguity

How at ease you are with open questions, mixed signals and problems without a single right answer. Research going back to the 1940s has explored how differently people respond to uncertainty and to the need for a firm answer. People high on this dimension can move forward before everything is clear. People lower on it prefer clarity and closure, which is exactly what gets projects finished and decisions made.

When does each style help?

No style wins everywhere. A few examples:

  • Careful analysis prevents costly mistakes in unfamiliar, high-stakes decisions, but it can slow you down when speed matters more than precision.
  • Intuition is fast and often wise, but only in the right conditions. In an influential paper, Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein (2009), two researchers who had long seemed to disagree, concluded together that intuition tends to be trustworthy when a setting is regular enough to learn from and a person has had plenty of practice with good feedback. A nurse with years on the same ward or an experienced chess player has earned their hunches. In a brand-new situation, the same quick feeling can mislead.
  • Wide curiosity sparks creative connections; focused interest builds deep expertise.
  • Open revision keeps you learning; steady conviction keeps you dependable.
  • Comfort with ambiguity keeps options open while a situation unfolds; a preference for clarity brings things to a close.

The most useful question is rarely "which style do I have?" It is "which style does this situation need, and is it the one I naturally reach for?"

Reading your own profile

Your result shows your score on each of the six dimensions, described in words rather than grades, and your leading style, or two leading styles when they stand out together. A few tips for reading it:

Look at your leading style as your default, not your limit. It is the way of thinking you most naturally reach for. You can and do use the others.

If nothing stands out, that is a finding too. Some people receive a balanced profile, "The Versatile Thinker", which usually describes a flexible, situation-led way of thinking. Others receive "The Grounded Pragmatist", when no style leads and one or more sit lower. That describes a practical, focused way of thinking that saves effort for what matters. It does not describe low ability.

Remember that self-report has limits. Your answers can be shaped by mood, tiredness, self-image and the setting you had in mind. Thinking styles also overlap with broader personality traits, especially openness to experience, which you can explore in the Big Five test. And the statements in Thinking Style are original and have not yet been validated in a published study. Treat your profile as a thoughtful starting point rather than a precise measurement.

Pick one stretch. Your results include concrete practices for the styles that come less naturally. If you rarely sit with a hard problem, try giving one a fixed, short block of time. If you usually trust your gut, try writing down two options and one risk for each before a big decision. If you crave closure, try leaving one low-stakes question open for a week and notice what you learn.

Thinking styles in teams

Teams often argue about how to decide when they think they are arguing about what to decide. One person wants more data; another wants to move. One keeps reopening the question; another wants it closed. Naming thinking styles can turn that friction into a division of labor: the deliberate reasoner checks the logic, the intuitive member flags what feels off, the wide roamer brings in an idea from elsewhere, and the person who prefers clarity makes sure something actually gets decided.

Used this way, the test is a shared, non-judgmental language. It must never be used for hiring, promotion or any other decision about a person. An organization sees your individual results only if you choose to share them, and team summaries, where used, show only anonymous group patterns.

Can your style change?

Thinking styles are fairly stable, but they are not fixed. They shift with experience, training, the demands of your work and the stage of your life. And you can practice a style that does not come naturally, which is often the most rewarding thing to do with your result. Retaking the test after a year or a big change can be interesting.

Discover how you like to think

If you have ever wondered why some tasks energize you and others drain you, or why you and a colleague keep approaching the same problem from opposite ends, take Thinking Style. It has 36 statements, takes about five minutes and has no right or wrong answers. Your results stay private unless you choose to share them.

Sources

  • Cacioppo, J. T., & Petty, R. E. (1982). The need for cognition. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 42(1), 116–131. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.42.1.116
  • Pacini, R., & Epstein, S. (1999). The relation of rational and experiential information processing styles to personality, basic beliefs, and the ratio-bias phenomenon. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76(6), 972–987. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.76.6.972
  • Stanovich, K. E., & West, R. F. (1997). Reasoning independently of prior belief and individual differences in actively open-minded thinking. Journal of Educational Psychology, 89(2), 342–357. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.89.2.342
  • von Stumm, S., & Ackerman, P. L. (2013). Investment and intellect: A review and meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 139(4), 841–869. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0030746
  • Kahneman, D., & Klein, G. (2009). Conditions for intuitive expertise: A failure to disagree. American Psychologist, 64(6), 515–526. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0016755
  • Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008). Learning styles: Concepts and evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 9(3), 105–119. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6053.2009.01038.x

Topics

  • thinking style
  • intuition
  • curiosity
  • decision making
  • open-mindedness